Select Page

Top 40 NBA Player Rankings Part 1

Written by Matlack

January 20, 2021

Read Part 2 here.

I am currently on a two month road trip to explore the Rocky Mountains and parts of the west coast. 

In the midst of the 25 hour drive from Philadelphia to Denver, my friend and I started debating the top 30 players in the NBA and who we thought deserved to be considered in the top tier. After comparing our thoughts we found that although there were many similarities there were a few minor differences that led to a fun debate. When we stopped in Chicago and included some other friends in the conversation those minor differences became major and turned into a full on debate. This debate included but was not limited to name calling, finger pointing, and I am pretty sure at one point a head shake so strong that the vibrations could be felt all the way across Lake Michigan. 

In this two part blog I will introduce my top 40 list. A few things to take note of:

  1. This is an art, not a science. By art I am referring to some Jean-Michel Basquiat type shit
  2. I am a sixers fan and admit my bias.
  3. In some cases I will make an argument about one player, just to totally contradict it with the next player. Again this is art.
  4. I will not be writing about every player but the ones that I think are the most interesting in their group of 10.
  5. The groupings of 10 are not tiers, they are simply convenient.
  6. Potential and playoff performance were heavily valued.
  7. Matisse Thybulle and Tyrese Maxey were not included but heavily considered.
  8. Klay Thompson was also not included because he will not play at any point this year. Rest up king(but not too much ;)). 

I now present my 21-40 ranked players.

40-31:

40. Zion Williamson

39. Zach LaVine

38. Malcolm Brogdon

37. De’Aaron Fox

36. Jrue Holiday

35. Pascal Siakam

34. Rudy Gobert

33. Kyle Lowry

32. Russell Westbrook

31. Devin Booker

Zach LaVine: I’ve been a hater of Zach LaVine’s in the past. I like the guy’s game and it sounds like he grinds in the offseason but it has not translated to winning basketball. One thing that is undeniable is that he has improved each season in the league and is continuing on that path this year. The Bulls are off to an average start but LaVine has been averaging career highs in points(top 5 in the NBA), assists, rebounds, FG%, and FT%. It is impossible to ignore him on a list like this.

Russell Westbrook: This might be my most controversial ranking but hear me out. I lived through the decline of Allen Iverson, my favorite player growing up. When players as explosive as Westbrook and Iverson lose their elite first step, acceleration, and overall athletic dominance they decline rapidly. That is what I am seeing from Russ. Right now he is ranked 156th in PER, averages 19.6 ppg(his lowest since 2010), and is shooting 40.5% from the field(his lowest since 2009). I think 32 is justified. 

Devin Booker: With the addition of Chris Paul we knew Booker’s role would change but I didn’t expect such a dip in production. Initially my gut feeling was to have him in the top 30 but his stats dropped from last year’s 26/4/6 to 22/3/4 this year, much more than I would’ve have expected. Although Booker is one of the most exciting young players in the league he has regressed with the Suns’ new look and so far this season is 116th in PER(out of 264 players). For these reasons I couldn’t rank him in my top 30 so naturally he is 31. 

30-21:

30. Khris Middleton

29. Jamal Murray

28. Nikola Vucevic

27. Donovan Mitchell

26. Domantas Sabonis

25. Jaylen Brown

24. Chris Paul

23. Ja Morant

22. Karl Anthony Towns

21. CJ McCollum 

Jamal Murray: Coming off the 2020 playoffs I think the entire basketball world was looking forward to seeing if Jamal Murray would take his game to the next level or at least continue his elite form. The fact is he has not. He is averaging 19/4/4 per game and is currently ranked 108 in PER for the league(he finished 2020 at 61). For comparison, Donovan Mitchell is ranked 63rd in the league for PER, Trae Young is 43rd, and, as mentioned, Devin Booker is 116th. Although I am still optimistic about Murray’s future I couldn’t rank him over a number of other guards in this ranking.

Domantas Sabonis: Sabonis is coming off his first all star appearance and is averaging a career best 21.7 points and 12.8 rebounds. It is hard to think of a guy more underrated in public NBA talk and will be the primary target for the Pacers moving forward. It is going to be fun to see what this guy will do the rest of the year, especially with this new looks Pacers lineup.

CJ McCollum vs KAT: It’s hard to say who you would want more for your team being they are such different players. KAT should be in the Unicorn conversation but has only made the playoffs once in his career and averaged 15 ppg in 5 games. CJ has always been an elite 2nd option and has taken it to the new level this year averaging 26 points and 5 assists, both career bests. For these reasons and I’ve liked CJ ever since I learned he went to Lehigh, I am putting CJ ahead. 

PER strives to measure a player’s per-minute performance, while adjusting for pace. A league-average PER is always 15.00, which permits comparisons of player performance across seasons.

Part 2 coming soon.

0 Comments

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. NBA Player Rankings Part Two: The Top 20 | - […] Read Part One here […]
  2. Bet Bath & Beyond: Episode 49 – The Bet Short (with guest Matlack) | - […] with B3T Sports blogger, Matlack. The three of them talk about the Top 40 Players in the NBA. Go…

Leave a Reply

Related Articles

Bet Bath & Beyond: Episode 76 – Heads or Tails from the Crypt

Bet Bath & Beyond: Episode 76 – Heads or Tails from the Crypt

Andy and Ian open up the podcast talking about the crypto bull market! Ethereum is pumping right now. All time high. Technically, not NFT talk, but don't worry Ian manages to talk about that too. Kentucky Derby recap and ranking horse names. For the first time in...

Bet Bath & Beyond: Episode 75 – Draft Day Special

Bet Bath & Beyond: Episode 75 – Draft Day Special

It’s Draft Day baby! Andy and Ian record during and after the first round of the 2021 NFL Draft. Listen to the bath boys react live to the Top 5 picks and hear Andy talk about killing himself if the Panthers draft Big Mac Jones. Don’t worry Andy, they just picked a...

Bet Bath & Beyond: Episode 74 – Nobetland

Bet Bath & Beyond: Episode 74 – Nobetland

Andy and Ian discuss the 93rd Academy Awards which aired over the weekend. They go down an Oscar rabbit hole and talk about all the great movies that were nominated over the last decade. A little bit of NFL news, the Ravens traded Orlando Brown Jr. to the Chiefs for...

%d bloggers like this: